Strict School Phone Bans Linked to Small Learning Gains in New Study
A Harvard, Dartmouth and NWEA analysis links locked-phone pouches to about one to two extra weeks of learning per year. The findings are modest, and earlier research reached a different conclusion.

Schools that required students to keep their phones in locked pouches during the school day saw small gains in math and reading achievement, according to a new national study released Tuesday.
Researchers from Harvard's Center for Education Policy Research, Dartmouth and NWEA estimated that the improvement was equivalent to about one to two additional weeks of learning each year. The findings suggest strict phone restrictions may help, but they do not point to a dramatic turnaround in student performance.
The team analyzed test-score data covering more than 3 million students over five school years. It compared achievement growth at schools that adopted locked-phone pouches with growth at similar schools that did not. The student-level analysis focused on 844 schools using both Yondr pouches and NWEA assessments.
The researchers reported that the small gains appeared to persist for up to three years after the policies were adopted. They also estimated that the restrictions reduced the number of phones used in schools by about 20 percent. The pouches cost roughly $25 per student.
The results come with important limits. The new study has not yet been peer-reviewed, and research on school phone bans remains mixed. A separate peer-reviewed study released in April found no meaningful overall achievement gains, although its approach and sample differed.
That earlier study examined average school-level scores across a larger group of schools, while the new analysis followed individual students in a smaller set of schools. The different methods make a simple comparison difficult.
The findings concern strict restrictions using lockable pouches, not every policy described as a phone ban. They also do not settle broader questions about children's phone use outside school, mental health or other outcomes. The researchers say further study is needed.